Sylvan Lake Shores Homes for Sale

Sylvan Lake Shores Homes for Sale

Welcome to Sylvan Lake Shores, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Winter Park, Florida. This picturesque subdivision is renowned for its serene surroundings, charming streets, and a strong sense of community that makes it one of the most desirable places to call home in Orange County. With its lush landscapes and tranquil lakes, Sylvan Lake Shores offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and suburban convenience.

The homes for sale in Sylvan Lake Shores range from elegant single-family residences to modern townhouses, catering to a variety of lifestyles and preferences. Many of these properties boast spacious layouts, contemporary finishes, and lush outdoor spaces ideal for entertaining or relaxing with family. Whether you’re looking for a cozy retreat or a luxurious haven, you’ll find a unique selection of homes that embody the warmth and charm of this inviting neighborhood.

Residents of Sylvan Lake Shores enjoy easy access to a wealth of amenities, including nearby parks, shopping districts, and top-rated schools. The vibrant downtown area of Winter Park is just a stone’s throw away, offering an array of dining, shopping, and cultural experiences. For outdoor enthusiasts, the nearby lakes provide opportunities for boating, fishing, and leisurely strolls along scenic trails.

Discover the enchanting lifestyle that awaits you in Sylvan Lake Shores. With homes for sale that reflect the essence of Florida living, this community is ready to welcome you home. Explore your options today and become part of a neighborhood that truly feels like family.

Newest Sylvan Lake Shores Homes for Sale

$2,190,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Sylvan Lake Shores SubDv. ⋅ 32789 Zip Code
Experience a rare expression of design-forward lakefront living on Lake Sylvan in the heart of Old Winter Park. Fully remodeled through a comprehensive, down-to-the-studs transformation, virtually every major component is new—giving this approximately 2,400-square-foot residence the quality, systems and finishes of a modern custom home. Framed by mature live oaks and sweeping 180-degree water views, the home combines refined craftsmanship and extraordinary lakefront serenity with warm European Contemporary architecture influenced by Belgian design and Organic Modern principles. Expansive, minimalist-profile windows frame the water from nearly every principal living space, while a dramatic 12-foot sliding glass wall connects the open living area to approximately 1,500 square feet of additional outdoor living. Multiple terraces, an integrated outdoor kitchen and beautifully landscaped surroundings create an exceptional setting for waterfront entertaining or quiet mornings beneath the oak canopy. Inside, natural wood, matte black accents, architectural lighting and tactile materials establish a cohesive, warm and inviting aesthetic. Custom white oak wall panels made in Spain, hand-cut white oak beams and architectural transitions, a textured brick feature wall, built-in Sonos audio and a dedicated entertaining bar reflect the attention given to every detail. The European-inspired kitchen features full-height cabinetry incorporating materials imported from Portugal, extensive integrated pantry storage, a Thermador appliance suite with a 36-inch range and griddle, and a Miele steam oven. Positioned at the heart of the living area, the kitchen creates an effortless setting for everyday life and entertaining, always with the lake close at hand. Each of the home’s three bedrooms includes a private en-suite full bath, with an additional powder room serving the common areas. A flexible lake-view office—currently used as a fitness and sauna studio—offers an inspiring setting for work, wellness or creative pursuits. The primary suite opens through nearly eight feet of accordion-style glass doors to a private rooftop terrace, inviting morning coffee, yoga, sunbathing or evening movies beneath the sky. Beyond its architectural design, the comprehensive transformation includes a new roof and roof components, electrical wiring, plumbing and piping, four-zone HVAC system, windows, stucco, drywall, flooring, kitchen and bathrooms. The result combines the character, proportions and established setting of an Old Winter Park home with the quality, efficiency and peace of mind expected from a modern custom residence. Turnkey, distinctive and intimately connected to the water, this exceptional home brings together architectural vision, modern livability and the coveted Winter Park lifestyle on the shores of Lake Sylvan.

1420 Aloma Avenue, Winter Park
$3,300,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Sylvan Lake Shores SubDv. ⋅ 32789 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Under Construction. Under construction. Experience approachable luxury combined with wellness-focused living in this newly crafted masterpiece by Urban Perch, a boutique home builder. In downtown Winter Park, this stunning new construction home offers 3,421 square feet of elegant, efficient living area. The primary residence features four bedrooms plus a generous flex space, the perfect office, home gym or playroom and 4.5 baths with designer fixtures and finishes. A separate casita with a full bath provides additional space for multigenerational living or as a private guesthouse. Upon entering, you are greeted by an expansive open-plan living area with soaring ceilings that effortlessly blends sophisticated style with indulging comfort. The kitchen is a culinary dream, equipped with Le Cornue and Monogram appliances, marble and quartzite countertops and a separate scullery with plenty of storage and ample prep space. The kitchen opens to one of the main living areas, featuring a precast concrete fireplace surround with exquisite millwork details, forming a focal point leading up to the angular ceiling and overhead beams. Engineered hardwood floors throughout and curated specialty tiles in wet spaces ensure the home maintains a clean, classic and modern feel. Floor-to-ceiling French doors and oversized sliders invite natural light and offer views of the beautifully landscaped grounds, including a sparkling heated saltwater pool and fully equipped outdoor kitchen. This wellness home incorporates advanced features to ensure a healthy living environment, from air and water purification systems to specialty lighting, all designed to promote a balanced lifestyle. Just moments from charming parks, highly rated restaurants and boutique shopping, 1627 Mizell Avenue is more than just a home, it’s a sanctuary. With excellent accessibility and a vibrant community, this is an ideal setting for those seeking a blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience.

1627 Mizell Avenue, Winter Park
$1,995,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Sylvan Lake Shores SubDv. ⋅ 32789 Zip Code
Welcome to your private slice of paradise, perfectly positioned on a charming brick-lined street in the heart of historic Winter Park. This custom-built estate exudes casual elegance from the moment you step through the grand double door entry, where soaring 12-foot ceilings, rich architectural details, and exceptional craftsmanship immediately set the tone. Thoughtfully designed with a well-balanced and highly functional floor plan, the home offers a seamless blend of formal and informal living spaces ideal for both everyday living and elevated entertaining. At the heart of the home, the pristine chef’s kitchen opens effortlessly to the family room and is outfitted with a built-in Thermador French door refrigerator, custom lighted cabinetry, granite countertops, a six-burner gas range with pot filler, double ovens with warming drawer, and an oversized island designed for gathering. A beautifully appointed butler’s pantry with wine fridge and wet bar creates the perfect transition to the formal dining space. Tucked away for privacy, a dedicated home office or library offers a quiet retreat for work or study. The first-floor primary suite is a true sanctuary, featuring intricate ceiling detail, expansive windows, and private French door access to the outdoor living space. The spa-inspired primary bath includes a jetted tub, dual vanities, and two oversized walk-in closets. Upstairs, three generously sized secondary bedrooms and two additional baths—including a private en suite—provide comfortable accommodations, while a charming Juliet balcony offers picturesque views of the tree-lined street below. Step outside to an exceptional outdoor living experience designed for year-round enjoyment. The covered lanai features a fully equipped summer kitchen with built-in grill, custom copper hood, and beverage fridge for the warmest Florida days. The saltwater pool creates a resort-style setting, surrounded by lush landscaping and enhanced by upgraded lighting and smart technology. This meticulously maintained home has been extensively upgraded, including new HVAC systems for both levels, on-demand water heater, whole-house surge protection, updated LED lighting with dimmer controls, smart home integrations for pool, irrigation, security, and climate, as well as complete interior and exterior repainting with premium finishes. High-end reclaimed maple and beech wood flooring has been installed and is complemented by refined architectural details such as curved archways, custom millwork, and elevated designer fixtures. Additional highlights include a newly created wine room, epoxy-coated garage flooring, central vacuum system, and enhanced exterior features with added awnings and detailed craftsmanship. Situated on a gorgeous lot with added privacy and with garage doors thoughtfully positioned away from the street, this home offers both presence and practicality. Just a short stroll to Lake Mizell and minutes from the renowned dining, shopping, and cultural experiences of Park Avenue, this exceptional property combines timeless design, modern upgrades, and an unbeatable location.

1398 Grove Terrace, Winter Park
Start Your Search